Professor Sports CardsThe hobby, straight
Fanatics, Topps, Panini & who runs the hobby

How sports cards went from a hobby to an industry

By Professor Sports Cards · from 2 live shows · In his words

Card shops, community and set building gave way to Fanatics, private equity, auction houses and breakers. Here's what changed and why I don't think it lasts.

The short answer

“What you're seeing here is an absolute industry. This has nothing to do with the hobby.”

Professor Sports Cards ·

I grew up with sports cards as a hobby. Somewhere in the last five or six years, that hobby turned into an industry. In The Great Collapse I laid out what the old world looked like, what replaced it, and why I don't think the new version holds up.

What the hobby used to be

The heart of the hobby was your local card shop. You didn't say 'I'm going to buy Fanatics product.' You went to the shop, spent time there, looked through boxes of raw cards and soaked in the nostalgia. There was real community. Set building was a huge part of it. And when it came to grading, you had choices: Beckett, PSA or CGC.

Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
The biggest thing you would think of when you thought about sports cards in the hobby, what was your hobby shop? It was your local card shop.
Watch on YouTube
Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
Set building definitely was a big part of the hobby.
Watch on YouTube

What changed

Now Fanatics runs the cards, Collectors and its private equity money run grading, and big auction houses have moved in. Instead of community, what you see on social media is sales, sales, sales. The breakers want to make their money, and while they make it feel like community, they're really pushing you to buy.

Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
Instead of seeing that community, what you see is sales, sales, sales.
Watch on YouTube

Set building has mostly disappeared. Newer products aren't made for building sets. They're made to sell more shiny product, because that's what an industry needs.

Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
This newer stuff isn't made to build sets. It is made to sell more shiny product, because it's an industry.
Watch on YouTube

From entertainment to gambling

Seven or eight years ago, stuff was still affordable and people bought cards for fun. You could buy a box for $150 at most. Now a new box can cost $1,200. At those prices, buying cards isn't entertainment anymore. It's gambling. And because these companies spent over a billion dollars to buy in, in my view they have to keep showing the boardroom growth.

Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
The old world, what we knew 7, 8 years ago, where stuff was still affordable, people were buying it for fun, as entertainment. Instead, when you're buying it, it's not quite entertainment. It's gambling.
Watch on YouTube
Professor Sports CardsThe Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry, Apr 18, 2026
They have to make the boardroom meetings. They have to continue to show growth and profit, no matter what, because lots of money moved in.
Watch on YouTube

What cards should be

I talked about this with Rocco, a former PSA employee, too. A lot of content makes cards out to be a Bugatti, something larger than life. That's not what cards are.

Professor Sports CardsRare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
A lot of them are making cards out to be like a Bugatti. It's supposed to be larger than life. And that's not what cards are.
Watch on YouTube
Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
Cards are a humble thing.
Watch on YouTube

Quotes are word for word from the streams, with filler words like "you know" taken out. Every ▶ plays the video from that exact moment. The article around them explains what was said; opinions are his.

📺 Catch the live show

Live every Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM ET (5 PM PT), with call-ins and guests from around the hobby.

Subscribe on YouTube

Watch the show

The Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry
Apr 18, 2026

The shows quoted here

The Great Collapse: Sports Cards Went From Hobby to Industry
Apr 18, 2026
Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee
Sep 7, 2025