Professor Sports CardsThe hobby, straight
Grading: PSA, CGC, SGC, BGS & TAG

Does PSA know when you crack a slab and resubmit the card?

By Professor Sports Cards · from 1 live show · In his words

Yes. According to a former PSA employee, every card is logged, and a card that has been graded before shows up with a flag when you send it back in.

The short answer

“There's a flag next to it, like, you know, this card has been submitted before.”

Rocco former PSA employee ·

Cracking a slab and sending the card back in, hoping a 9 comes back a 10, is one of the most common plays in the hobby. A lot of people assume PSA has no idea it's the same card. According to Rocco, who worked in PSA's research department, that's not true.

Yes: resubmitted cards get flagged

Rocco saw it all the time. Someone gets an 8, doesn't like it, cracks the case and sends the card back. When it comes back through, researchers can see that it has already been through the system.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
What happens often is you'll see an order that comes back with a card that's already went through the system. This person cracked the case. He got an eight. Didn't like the fact that he got an eight. He cracks the case. He sends the card back in.
Watch on YouTube
Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
But so, we know. We know.
Watch on YouTube

That was news to me, and I said so on the spot.

Professor Sports CardsRare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
Wait a minute. That's big news. So PSA does know.
Watch on YouTube

How does PSA know it's the same card?

I pushed him on this. A serial-numbered card is easy: if the 3 of 49 you sent last time shows up again, they know it's the same card. But what about a card with no number? Rocco couldn't remember the exact process, but he was clear on the result: every card is logged, and a card that's been submitted before shows up with a flag next to it. To find it, researchers go back to the original order. (For the full path a card takes, see what happens when you send cards to PSA.)

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
I mean, every card is logged, you know?
Watch on YouTube
Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
There's a flag next to it, like, you know, this card has been submitted before.
Watch on YouTube

Does the flag hurt your chances?

Professor Sports CardsRare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
I don't think the general public knows that PSA knows.
Watch on YouTube

Quotes are word for word from the streams, with filler words like "you know" taken out. Every ▶ plays the video from that exact moment. The article around them explains what was said; opinions are his.

📺 Catch the live show

Live every Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM ET (5 PM PT), with call-ins and guests from around the hobby.

Subscribe on YouTube

Watch the show

Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee
Sep 7, 2025

Common questions

Is every card logged at PSA?

Yes. Rocco said every card is logged, which is how a resubmitted card gets flagged.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
I mean, every card is logged, you know?
Watch on YouTube

More on grading