What percentage of cards get a PSA 10?
By Professor Sports Cards · from 2 live shows · In his wordsIn the orders one former PSA researcher saw, about 25 to 30 percent of cards came back 10s on average. Here's why the 9-versus-10 gap matters so much.
“Usually it's about 25 to 30% get tens, on average.”
Everyone sending cards to PSA is chasing the 10. So how many actually get one? Rocco saw thousands of orders while he worked in PSA's research department, and he gave me a rough number.
About 25 to 30 percent, in the orders he saw
When Rocco went back through original orders, roughly a quarter to 30 percent of the cards in an order came back 10s on average, sometimes a little more, sometimes a little less. It's not an official PSA number, just what one researcher saw day after day.
If you look, usually it's about 25 to 30% get tens, on average. Sometimes a little bit more, sometimes a little bit less.
And his own submission? He sent 25 cards while he worked there. He got about ten 9s, which he was happy with, and zero 10s.
I submitted 25 cards. I got like 10 nines, which I was happy about. I got no tens.
Why the 9-versus-10 gap matters so much
This is the part I keep coming back to. The gap between a 9 and a 10 is the gap between a car and a dinner. Take a Griffey Upper Deck rookie: get a 10 and it's a $4,500 card. Get a 9 and you've got about $300. That's how much power the grade has over the price.
They control single prices. When you send your card in, that Griffey rookie Upper Deck, if you get a 10, you struck rich. It's a $4,500 card.
If you get a nine on that same card, no, you're not going to buy a new car. You got $300 and maybe you go for dinner.
Quotes are word for word from the streams, with filler words like "you know" taken out. Every ▶ plays the video from that exact moment. The article around them explains what was said; opinions are his.
Live every Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM ET (5 PM PT), with call-ins and guests from around the hobby.
Subscribe on YouTubeWatch the show
Common questions
Does sending multiple copies lower your chance at a 10?
It can, according to a PSA supervisor's advice to Rocco: copies in the same order get judged against each other.
You could send in three cards, they could all be tens, but if they're looking at them, they're going to judge them against each other and one will get a better grade than the other.