Professor Sports CardsThe hobby, straight
Grading: PSA, CGC, SGC, BGS & TAG

Should you send multiple copies of the same card to PSA in one order?

By Professor Sports Cards · from 1 live show · In his words

A former PSA employee's boss told him no: copies of the same card in one order get compared to each other, so split them across different orders.

The short answer

“Whenever multiples, send them in on different orders.”

Rocco former PSA employee ·

Say you pulled three copies of the same rookie and they all look clean. The obvious move is to send them in together. Rocco, who worked in PSA's research department, got the opposite advice from his own boss.

The tip: don't send multiples in the same order

Rocco had multiples of some cards, like his Jeters, and mentioned it to his boss. His boss told him not to send them together. The reasoning: when graders look at several copies of the same card side by side, they compare them, and they'll make sure one comes out better than the other. Three cards that could all be 10s on their own might not all get 10s when they're judged against each other.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
He told me, don't send in the multiples. If you send in the multiples, there's less of a chance that you're going to get a 10, because they're going to make sure that one is better than the other.
Watch on YouTube
Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
You could send in three cards, they could all be tens, but if they're looking at them, they're going to judge them against each other and one will get a better grade than the other.
Watch on YouTube

His boss's answer was simple: split them up.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
So whenever multiples, send them in on different orders.
Watch on YouTube
This was one boss's advice to an employee, not a PSA policy. But it came from inside the building, and it costs you nothing to follow: send copies of the same card on different orders.

Why multiples stand out inside PSA

Here's the funny part. From the researchers' side, an order full of the same card is the best kind of order there is. Rocco said an order of 45 copies of the same Jayden Daniels Topps Now card takes five to ten minutes. So those orders move fast, but every copy is sitting right next to the others.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
The best orders are you get 45 of the Jayden Daniels Topps Now card. They're literally 45 of the same card and boom. You're done with that order in five to 10 minutes.
Watch on YouTube

Quotes are word for word from the streams, with filler words like "you know" taken out. Every ▶ plays the video from that exact moment. The article around them explains what was said; opinions are his.

📺 Catch the live show

Live every Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM ET (5 PM PT), with call-ins and guests from around the hobby.

Subscribe on YouTube

Watch the show

Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee
Sep 7, 2025

Common questions

What percentage of cards get a PSA 10?

In the orders Rocco saw at PSA, about 25 to 30 percent of cards came back 10s on average.

Roccoformer PSA employee · Rare Interview With Former PSA Employee, Sep 7, 2025
If you look, usually it's about 25 to 30% get tens, on average. Sometimes a little bit more, sometimes a little bit less.
Watch on YouTube

More on grading